7 Things To Look For When Thrift Store Crafting (Plus What To Avoid)

In this post, we’ll go over the best things to hunt for on your next thrift store crafting trip, plus a few things you’ll want to skip.

As a kid, I grew up garage sale hunting on weekends and taking plenty of trips to the thrift store with my parents. Back then, I was on the lookout for Barbies and Polly Pockets. These days, I’m looking for things to use in my latest craft projects instead.

Crafting with secondhand items is honestly the best. Not only do you save some money, but there’s already so much stuff on this planet, so any little way I can reduce waste is a win in my book.

Here are the 7 things I always look for when thrift store crafting, plus a couple of things I steer clear of.

What To Look For When Thrift Store Crafting

1. Vases

There are so many simple upcycling ideas you can do with vases. You can paint them, tint them, decoupage them, or add a ribbon for a quick and easy upgrade. They’re one of the easiest thrift finds to transform.

2. Children’s Books

Look for anything with illustrations you love. I personally love Disney, so I always have my eyes peeled for Little Golden Books or other vintage Disney books. You can use old children’s books for handmade cards, or use the illustrations as framed artwork. Check out even more ideas for upcycling children’s books.

3. Sheets & Tablecloths

Fabric is expensive! If you can thrift pretty sheets or tablecloths, you’ve got a great start on your fabric stash. Scrunchies are my favorite beginner project, but there are also plenty of no-sew projects if you’re just getting started with fabric crafting.

4. Picture Frames

Thrift stores are always filled with picture frames. Find one whose shape you like and make it your own. You can paint them, add embellishments, or add some fabric to give them something special.

5. Craft Tools

Let’s be real, craft supplies can get pricey, especially when you’re like me and always want to try out a new craft. And who really wants to pay full price for that one super-specific tool you don’t plan on using often? The good news is thrift stores are often loaded with craft supplies. Keep your eyes open and see what you find.

6. Small Trinkets

I love turning small trinkets or toys into keychains/bag charms. The easiest way to do this is to look for soft items you can easily punch or drill a hole into. They’re super simple to make, plus it’s a bonus if you find something nostalgic that brings you right back to your inner child.

7. Wooden Items

Look for good bases here. Wooden items are great for personalizing and turning into home decor, whether that’s a sign, a tray, or something totally your own.

Things To Avoid

Damaged Or Moldy Items

This one might be a no-brainer, but skip anything that’s broken, moldy, or in really bad condition. If it looks like a health hazard, just leave it at the thrift store. 😂

Overpriced “Cheap” Materials

My local thrift store often sells Dollar Tree items for more than they cost at the Dollar Tree itself. 🙄 Be careful not to buy things that aren’t durable, especially if the pricing doesn’t actually make sense.

Quick Tips For Thrift Store Crafting

Keep A Running List

I like to keep a running thrift list in my notes app. Of course, you won’t always find exactly what’s on it, but it helps to know what you’re looking for and jot things down whenever you’re feeling inspired for a certain project. It also helps you avoid overbuying just because something’s cheap. You want to be mindful and not bring home junk you won’t actually use, so shop with a purpose in mind.

Thrift Often

This doesn’t mean you need to buy something every single trip, but visiting your favorite thrift store often is a good habit. New items get donated all the time, and good finds tend to get scooped up quickly.

Final Thoughts

There are so many great items you can find at the thrift store once you know what to look for. A little patience (and a running list) goes a long way toward turning a regular thrift trip into a haul full of your next favorite project.

Ready for more inspiration? Check out my other upcycled projects for more thrift store crafting ideas, and let me know in the comments what you always look for when you’re thrifting!